Damage-Displacement: Spiral Reinforced
  Download Damage-Displacement Table       DISPLACEMENT (mm)      
No. Specimen Name Crushing Spalling Buckling Long. Bar fracture Spiral fracture Loss of Axial Failure
1 Davey 1975, No. 1 65.0 65.0 65.0       65.0
2 Davey 1975, No. 2 61.0 61.0 82.0       82.0
3 Davey 1975, No. 3 41.0 87.0 87.0       87.0
4 Munro et al. 1976, No. 1 38.0 76.0         0.0
5 Ng et al. 1978, No. 2             0.0
6 Ng et al. 1978, No. 3 10.0 20.0         0.0
7 Ang et al. 1981, No. 1 15.0   60.0 60.0 60.0   60.0
8 Ang et al 1981, No. 2 9.8 26.0 50.0       52.0
9 Potangaroa et al. 1979, No. 1 10.0 20.0         0.0
10 Potangaroa et al. 1979, No. 3             0.0
11 Potangaroa et al. 1979, No. 4 7.5 15.0         0.0
12 Potangaroa et al. 1979, No. 5A             0.0
13 Potangaroa et al. 1979, No. 5B             0.0
14 Ang et al. 1985, No. 1             0.0
15 Ang et al. 1985, No. 2             0.0
16 Ang et al. 1985, No. 3             0.0
17 Ang et al. 1985, No. 4             0.0
18 Ang et al. 1985, No. 5             0.0
19 Ang et al. 1985, No. 6             0.0
20 Ang et al. 1985, No. 7             0.0
21 Ang et al. 1985, No. 8             0.0
22 Ang et al. 1985, No. 9             0.0
23 Ang et al. 1985, No. 10             0.0
24 Ang et al. 1985, No. 11             0.0
25 Ang et al. 1985, No. 12             0.0
26 Ang et al. 1985, No. 13             0.0
27 Ang et al. 1985, No. 14             0.0
28 Ang et al. 1985, No. 15             0.0
29 Ang e. al. 1985, No. 16             0.0
30 Ang et al. 1985, No. 17             0.0
31 Ang et al. 1985, No. 18             0.0
32 Ang et al. 1985, No. 19             0.0
33 Ang et al. 1985, No. 20             0.0
34 Ang et al. 1985, No. 21             0.0
35 Ang et al. 1985, No. 22             0.0
36 Ang et al. 1985, No. 23             0.0
37 Ang et al. 1985, No. 24             0.0
38 Ang et al. 1985, No. 25             0.0
39 Zahn et al. 1986, No. 5   22.8 45.6 80.0     45.6
40 Zahn et al. 1986, No. 6             0.0
41 Watson & Park 1989, No 10   18.9     31.5   31.5
42 Watson & Park 1989, No 11   10.1 36.3       36.3
43 Wong et al. 1990, No. 1 6.0 9.6 41.4   40.0 40.0 40.0
44 Wong et al. 1990, No. 2             0.0
45 Wong et al. 1990, No. 3   9.7 28.8       25.9
46 Petrovski & Ristic 1984, M1E1             0.0
47 Petrovsky & Ristic 1984, M1E2             0.0
48 Petrovsky & Ristic 1984, M2E1             0.0
49 Petrovsky & Ristic 1984, M2E2             0.0
50 Lim et al. 1990, Con1             0.0
51 Lim et al. 1990, Con1             0.0
52 Lim et al. 1990, Con1             0.0
53 NIST, Full Scale Flexure 179.0 269.0 538.0 538.0 538.0   538.0
54 NIST, Full Scale Shear   142.0 285.0 356.0 356.0   285.0
55 NIST, Model N1 19.3 38.6 82.5 77.2     77.2
56 NIST, Model N2   33.5 46.6 55.9 55.9   44.7
57 NIST, Model N3 51.2 76.8 110.6 102.4 76.8   76.8
58 NIST, Model N4 21.3 32.0 53.3 53.3 53.3   53.3
59 NIST, Model N5 19.3 29.0 52.2 48.3 48.3   48.3
60 NIST, Model N6 33.6 67.2 71.5 100.8 67.2   67.2
61 BRI No. 2 (Japan), spbaa1     9.0       9.0
62 BRI No. 3 (Japan), ws21bs             0.0
63 BRI No. 3 (Japan), ws22bs             0.0
64 BRI No. 3 (Japan), ws25bs             0.0
65 BRI No. 3 (Japan), ws26bs             0.0
66 BRI No. 3 (Japan), ws27bs             0.0
67 Arakawa et al. 1987, No. 1             0.0
68 Arakawa et al. 1987, No. 2             0.0
69 Arakawa et al. 1987, No. 3             0.0
70 Arakawa et al. 1987, No. 4             0.0
71 Arakawa et al. 1987, No. 6             0.0
72 Arakawa et al. 1987, No. 8             0.0
73 Arakawa et al. 1987, No. 9             0.0
74 Arakawa et al. 1987, No. 10             0.0
75 Arakawa et al. 1987, No. 11             0.0
76 Arakawa et al. 1987, No. 12             0.0
77 Arakawa et al. 1987, No. 13             0.0
78 Arakawa et al. 1987, No. 14             0.0
79 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 15             0.0
80 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 16             0.0
81 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 17             0.0
82 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 18             0.0
83 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 19             0.0
84 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 20             0.0
85 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 21             0.0
86 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 22             0.0
87 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 23             0.0
88 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 24             0.0
89 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 25             0.0
90 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 26             0.0
91 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 27             0.0
92 Arakawa et al. 1988, No. 28             0.0
93 Kunnath et al. 1997, A2   40.0 64.5   76.2   68.3
94 Kunnath et al. 1997, A3 27.0 27.0         0.0
95 Kunnath et al. 1997, A4         57.0   57.0
96 Kunnath et al. 1997, A5       75.0     75.0
97 Kunnath et al. 1997, A6         75.0   75.0
98 Kunnath et al. 1997, A7 20.0 80.0 80.0   80.0   80.0
99 Kunnath et al. 1997, A8 32.0 58.0 80.0   80.0   80.0
100 Kunnath et al. 1997, A9   63.0 63.0   90.0   63.0
101 Kunnath et al. 1997, A10 32.0 50.0 90.7   82.0   82.0
102 Kunnath et al. 1997, A11 50.0 105.0   105.0 105.0   105.0
103 Kunnath et al. 1997, A12 50.0 81.0 81.0   81.0   81.0
104 Benzoni & Priestley 1994, NR1 14.4   57.6   57.6   57.6
105 Benzoni & Priestley 1994, NR2 11.4           0.0
106 Hose et al., 1997, SRPH1 60.0 80.0 320.0 320.0     320.0
107 Vu et al. 1998, NH1 11.5 11.5 0.0 46.0 0.0 0.0 46.0
108 Vu et al. 1998, NH2 22.5 22.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
109 Vu et al. 1998, NH3 18.8 18.8 50.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 50.0
110 Vu et al. 1998, NH4 0.0 21.3 85.0 0.0 85.0 0.0 85.0
111 Vu et al. 1998, NH5 21.0 21.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
112 Vu et al. 1998, NH6 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
113 Kowalsky et al. 1996, FL1   83.0 332.0 332.0     332.0
114 Kowalsky et al. 1996, FL2 70.0 70.0 210.0   210.0   210.0
115 Kowalsky et al. 1996, FL3 68.0 102.0 340.0 340.0     340.0
116 Lehman et al. 1998, 415 38.1   129.0 178.0 135.0   135.0
117 Lehman et al. 1998, 815 133.0 178.0 445.0 445.0 445.0   445.0
118 Lehman et al. 1998, 1015 191.0 254.0 635.0 635.0 635.0   635.0
119 Lehman et al.1998, 407 38.0 38.1 127.0 127.0 127.0   127.0
120 Lehman et al. 1998, 430 38.1 50.8 178.0   178.0   178.0
121 Calderone et al. 1998, 328 30.0   133.0 132.0 132.0   125.0
122 Calderone et al. 1998, 828 178.0   600.0   750.0   600.0
123 Calderone et al. 1998,1028 254.0   889.0   889.0   889.0
124 Sritharan et al. 1995, IC1             0.0
125 Sritharan et al. 1995, B105IC2             0.0
126 Sritharan et al. 1995, IC3             0.0
127 Saatcioglu & Baingo 1999, RC1             0.0
128 Saatcioglu & Baingo 1999, RC2             0.0
129 Saatcioglu & Baingo 1999, RC3             0.0
130 Saatcioglu & Baingo 1999, RC4             0.0
131 Saatcioglu & Baingo 1999, RC6     68.4       65.8
132 Saatcioglu & Baingo 1999, RC7             0.0
133 Saatcioglu & Baingo 1999, RC8       really buckle74     74.0
134 Saatcioglu & Baingo 1999, RC9             0.0
135 Nelson & Price 2000, Col1   30.0 47.5   47.5 53.8 47.5
136 Nelson & Price 2000, Col2   56.6 56.6   56.6 89.9 56.6
137 Nelson & Price 2000, Col3   29.2 47.8   47.8 57.9 47.8
138 Nelson & Price 2000, Col4   45.0 45.0   45.0 45.7 45.0
139 Nelson & Price 2003, Col5     46.3        
140 Nelson & Price 2003, Col6     33.0        
141 Henry 1998, 415p     127.0 135.0 127.0   127.0
142 Henry 1998, 415s     127.0   127.0   127.0
143 Chai, Priestley, and Seible 1991, Test 3             0.0
144 Soderstrom 2001,C1 39.4            
145 Soderstrom 2001,C2 34.4            
146 Soderstrom 2001,C3              
147 Soderstrom 2001,C4              
148 Graff, 2001,C5              
149 Graff, 2001,C6              
150 Graff, 2001,C7              
151 Graff, 2001,C8              
152 Kowalsky & Moyer, 2001, 1 73.7   149.9 186.7      
153 Kowalsky & Moyer, 2001, 2 55.9   261.6 299.7      
154 Kowalsky & Moyer, 2001, 3 73.7   261.9   261.9    
155 Kowalsky & Moyer, 2001, 4 73.7   335.3        
156 Coffman et al. 1993, Column 1              
157 Hamilton, 2002, UCI1              
158 Hamilton, 2002, UCI2              
159 Hamilton, 2002, UCI3              
160 Hamilton, 2002, UCI4              
161 Hamilton, 2002, UCI5              
162 Hamilton, 2002, UCI6              
163 McDaniel, 1997, S1   1          
164 McDaniel, 1997, S1-2   1          
165 McDaniel, 1997, S2              
166 Ohtaki et al, 1997, L1              
167 Iwasaki, 1985, P-26              
168 Iwasaki, 1985, P-30              
169 Xiao et al, 1999, CS-A              
170 Benzoni et al, 1996, CS1              
171 Benzoni et al, 1996, CS2              
172 Benzoni et al, 1996, CS3              
173 Benzoni et al, 1996, CS4              
174 Verma et al, 1993, 1              
175 Verma et al, 1993, 3              
176 Verma et al, 1993, 5              
177 Verma et al, 1993, 7